Thanti Mthanti - SA’s fiscal policy and macro-econ
Posted on 3 December 2021 by Thanti Mthanti
Leadership & Ethics

SA’s fiscal policy and macro-economic framework hang in the balance as parties jostle for power

The political balance of power is shifting to the poor majority, making pro-poor human capital investment more likely.


Earlier in November, finance minister Enoch Godongwana delivered his maiden medium-term budget policy statement in very turbulent political waters. For the first time since coming into power in 1994, as the contesting factions tear it apart, the ANC is facing the prospect of losing power. In the 2024 general elections, the governing party may struggle to garner fifty plus one percent of the vote, which may have interesting implications for fiscal policy and South Africa’s broader macro-economic framework.

Some caveats. We know that the debt ratio does not equate to all government liabilities. The monetary base and other prospective/contingent liabilities are equally important. Similarly, we know that the primary surplus is only one variable in the debt consolidation equation. Curbing the interest-growth differential — the rate at which a country's public debt rises relative to the growth of its output — and preventing contingent liabilities from materialising, might be even more essential for stabilising the country’s finances.

For instance, high interest payments might be the primary cause of the debt accumulation that we have seen since the hawkish Lesetja Kganyago was appointed SARB governor. In fact, they now gobble 21 cents of every rand of revenue — more than what the government spends on health, social development, and policing. Similarly, “contingent liabilities” are quite critical for the sovereign’s debt dynamics. Many state-owned enterprises, not least power utility Eskom and SAA, have huge government-backed debt that they can’t service. In fact, National Treasury is already paying back principal and interest on this debt.

Nevertheless, despite the caveats about the importance of the interest-growth differential and stock-flow adjustments for debt sustainability, the political dynamics around taxing and spending in the main budget are still crucial for restoring the fiscal health of the sovereign in the coming years.

Political self-interest may empty the public purse 

So, what does that entail in the real new dawn ushered in by the 2021 local government elections? We know from the literature that we are more likely to see fiscal slippage in parliamentary systems that allocate seats based on proportional representation than in majoritarian systems. Competitive proportional representation systems tend to be associated with larger governments providing universal welfare; moreover, they tend to suffer from common pool problems.

Essentially, each coalition partner is likely to pursue its own self-interest, resulting in the overexploitation and consequently, the emptying, of the public purse. In fact, we are increasingly seeing this outcome in unstable DA- or ANC-led coalition governments at the local level, and it's difficult to see what will stop this parasitic rent-seeking at the national level should coalitions become the order of the day post 2024. 

Moreover, the ANC may not meekly surrender its majority and render itself beholden to coalition partners without trying to maintain its parliamentary majority. In contexts such as SA, with a low share of informed voters, ruling parties facing a real prospect of electoral defeat are tempted to undertake a spending binge as they desperately try to hold onto power. As political contestation intensifies as we get closer to 2024 and the keys to the Union Buildings are at risk, it will not be surprising if the ANC is not preaching fiscal prudence to a hungry electorate; instead, it may be spending as if there's no tomorrow. The cost of this extravagance to the party may be small, and the returns large because ill-informed voters may fail to understand that their bounty is from pre-electoral manipulations and not from ruling party competence.

For both these reasons — political budget cycles and rent seeking in proportional representation systems — the 2021 local government elections may not only mark the end of ANC political dominance, but also the end of the neo-liberalism that has dominated economic policymaking since 1994. So, despite the protestations of the finance minister and the preaching of tough love, as political realities bite and political entrepreneurs weigh their risk-reward scenarios, fiscal prudence might be thrown out of the window.

ANC stinginess may not survive the 2024 political realities

It could be argued that this may not be a bad outcome for the country if it largely entails much-needed investment in human capital, including the basic income grant (BIG) and the national health insurance (NHI) system. In fact, neoliberal dominance has been such that even though 44,4% of the labour force has no income, and a R350 BIG costs less than 1% of national income, it has been resisted by the ruling party. Yes, you read that right — the ruling party refuses to allocate 1% of national income to 44,4% of the labour force. Such stinginess may not survive the 2024 political realities.

Finally, 27 years after the first democratic gains, much needed human capital investments to address the apartheid legacy and diversify the economy away from commodities towards a human capital centered growth path, may be possible.

However, opportunities also bring risks. Weak politicians who cannot tax elites may instead fund long-term investments using short-term debt and monetary financing. And spending without countervailing revenue measures could put the country's finances on an unsustainable path. Similarly, putting pressure on the Reserve Bank to fund a bankrupt fiscus will only accelerate inflation, impoverishing the very poor the politicians will be claiming to help. As we have seen elsewhere, popular policies like the BIG and the NHI meant to achieve equity, and growth, can have disastrous effects.

The 2021 breakthrough, however, need not be all doom and gloom for the country. It is very clear the political balance of power is shifting and in turn, productivity enhancing human capital investment is more likely. Nevertheless, to counter the threat of weak governments discrediting much needed comprehensive welfare reform and the NHI, and to ensure fiscal solvency and monetary predictability as we begin to address our human capital deficit and diversify our economy, parliament may need to enact tougher fiscal rules including adopting an explicit debt ceiling. Strict fiscal rules may compel weak politicians to appropriate resources from elites to fund their spending priorities without risking defaults and inflation that would discredit welfare reform and the NHI.

There’s still a long way to go before the next election, but SA will be better off making a move now to guard against the delegitimisation of much-needed human capital investments, which are crucial for the economic diversification and consequently, the development of the country.

Dr Mthanti, PRM™ is a senior lecturer in finance at the University of Cape Town’s Graduate School of Business. 


MORE ON Leadership & Ethics

Innovation
Leadership & Ethics

UCT GSB's Executive MBA programme finalist in prestigious Evidence-Based Leadership Development Award

The UCT GSB’s EMBA programme was one of five finalists for the prestigious Evidence-Based Leadership Development Programme Award by the Academy of Management’s Management Education and Development Division – a testament to the UCT GSB's commitment to excellence in leadership education.

Read Article
Posted on 11 July 2024 by UCT GSB Press Office
VBL Pin Image
Leadership & Ethics

Transforming the role of business in society through values-based leadership

The Allan Gray Centre for Values-Based Leadership explores ‘new ways of doing business based on purpose, sustainability and responsible practices'

Read Article
Posted on 11 March 2024 by UCT GSB Press Office
Future-proofing 690x345
Leadership & Ethics

Future-Proofing Your Skills: Adapting for Tomorrow's Challenges Today

In honour of Women's Day, the UCT GSB hosted a panel discussion on campus the UCT GSB hosted a panel discussion, on campus, featuring alumni and guests to discuss how best to future-proof your skills.

Read Article
Posted on 21 September 2023 by Alumni Relations Dept
CEMS Report leading for future of planet PIN
Leadership & Ethics

A new model of collective business leadership and a shift to generational strategic thinking are essential to avert environmental catastrophe

New CEMS report sets out recommendations for globally responsible business leaders, educators and young professionals

Read Article
Posted on 28 October 2022 by UCT GSB Press Office
DR NAMANE MAGAU, HAS PASSED AWAY
Leadership & Ethics

UCT GSB Advisory Board Member, Dr Namane Magau, has passed away

It is with great sadness that we mourn the passing of Dr Namane Magau, a long-serving member of the UCT GSB’s Advisory Board, a friend of our School and University and an extraordinary woman and role model whose influence continues to reach across South Africa and around the world.

Read Article
Posted on 27 May 2022 by UCT GSB Press Office
Trust and Governance: why trust is key to economic
Leadership & Ethics

Trust and Governance: why trust is key to economic performance

Trust greatly reduces transaction costs within an economy and society. Just as a functional health care system will produce healthy citizens, trustworthy governing officials help to create trustworthy citizens.

Read Article
Posted on 31 March 2022 by Thomas Koelble
ADDRESSING THE LACK OF JEDI IN THE WORKPLACE
Leadership & Ethics

Addressing the lack of JEDI in the workplace

The South African workplace remains a very complex space. To bring about a change in workplace culture and organisational orientations, we may need to consider new approaches. Recent research from the UCT GSB has highlighted several practices that organisations can implement to help address the lack of justice, equality, diversity and inclusion in the workplace.

Read Article
Posted on 10 February 2022 by Kurt April
Here’s why black Millennial women are leaving 2
Leadership & Ethics

Here’s why black millennial women are leaving your organisation

New research digs into the deep frustration causing many African millennial women to call it a day at the office.

Read Article
Posted on 8 February 2022 by Kurt April
Poetic licence to lead through challenging times
Leadership & Ethics

Poetic licence to lead through challenging times

With employees stressed, business leaders worried, and mental health challenges skyrocketing, conventional approaches to preparing leaders for the business world may not be enough. The foundational role of the leader as communicator is more important than ever – and poetry could unlock the deeper self-awareness and connection needed to lead through ambiguity.

Read Article
Posted on 21 November 2021 by Babar Dharani
Aidan
Leadership & Ethics

Servant leadership may be the key to talent retention post COVID

Nike strategy director for Europe, the Middle East, and Africa, Aidan Kearney, believes servant leadership has so much to offer the corporate world, especially now as an increasing number of employees think of leaving their jobs in response to the stresses of the COVID-19 workplace.

Read Article
Posted on 17 November 2021 by UCT GSB Press Office
Fortune Gamanya
Leadership & Ethics

Crisis ushers in new type of leadership – this time it must stick

The COVID-19 pandemic has tested leadership in ways that few crises have. How do we learn from it, adapt and evolve as leaders?

Read Article
Posted on 20 October 2021 by UCT GSB Press Office
Joy-Marie Lawrence
Leadership & Ethics

Activists in the Boardroom holistic governance in an age of corporate malfeasance

Given the recent spate of corporate misconduct (think Steinhoff, EOH, the Guptas and various State-Owned Entities), more Boardroom activism is required to ensure accountability and prevent future scandals. Board directors should start by cultivating higher levels of self-awareness.

Read Article
Posted on 20 October 2021 by UCT GSB Press Office
Kosheek Sewchurran Can we risk our society’s futur
Leadership & Ethics

Can we risk our society’s future on a system that produces the leadership we experience?

The events of the past two weeks have brought into sharp focus the devastating results of selecting leaders based on popularity over other criteria. To avoid shipwrecking our country, it’s time to design a better system of stewarding our collective needs.

Read Article
Posted on 23 July 2021 by Kosheek Sewchurran
Kurt April - Bhuda
Leadership & Ethics

Making space for Buddha in the boardroom

A new study shows that by staying true to the founding principles of the Buddhist meditation technique known as mindfulness, business leaders can reimagine not just how they work, but also how to build stronger relationships in the workplace.

Read Article
Posted on 10 May 2021 by Kurt April
Jody Delichte  - Freedom and Democracy
Leadership & Ethics

Becoming a businessperson is not a straightforward journey for all

Building business skills to improve livelihoods is increasingly being recognised as a mechanism to lift communities out of extreme poverty. But in many survivalist communities, the principles of business can clash with the existing values of the community.

Read Article
Posted on 20 April 2021 by UCT GSB Press Office
Beyond lip service - Media
Leadership & Ethics

Beyond lip service, how do we create more inclusive workplaces?

In South Africa and globally, companies are struggling to put a commitment to diversity and inclusion into practice.

Read Article
Posted on 14 April 2021 by Kumeshnee West
leaders must seek - Kosheek S
Leadership & Ethics

Can business leaders ignite change in a world that is overdue a great reset?

The thinking that has informed business leadership will not see us through the present challenges we face. To remake the world we need to recognise the deficiencies in leadership we experience and change how we train future leaders.

Read Article
Posted on 18 February 2021 by Kosheek Sewchurran
Alforde Charumbira AACSB - MEDIA
Leadership & Ethics

UCT GSB MBA alumnus, Alforde Charumbira honoured in the AACSB's Influential Leaders challenge

This annual initiative recognises notable graduates from AACSB-accredited business schools around the world, who are using their business education to create lasting impact in their own, unique way.

Read Article
Posted on 16 February 2021 by UCT GSB Press Office
Q&A with new UCT GSB - media
Leadership & Ethics

The future of business, business schools and the economy

UCT GSB Director, Dr Catherine Duggan, shares her thoughts on the future of business education and how to prepare students for an increasingly complex world.

Read Article
Posted on 7 December 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
sustainable leadership ball - media
Leadership & Ethics

Africa can lead the way in the great reset and its leaders have a key role to play

If Africa is to emerge a better society post-COVID-19, the approach to leadership and the broader environment needs to change.

Read Article
Posted on 1 December 2020 by Camille Meyer
intelligence in leadership - media
Leadership & Ethics

Why we should trust subtlety over the posturing of a heroic leader

Emotionally intelligent leaders will be crucial in helping us to navigate through the COVID-19 crisis and the fallout from the US election chaos.

Read Article
Posted on 23 November 2020 by Kosheek Sewchurran
martin luther - media
Leadership & Ethics

Leaders are not born or made, they are honed through practice and reflection

In times of crisis, the need for good leadership is paramount, but how can we develop more leaders who are able to meet the moment with wisdom and compassion?

Read Article
Posted on 20 October 2020 by Kosheek Sewchurran
Catherine Duggan
Leadership & Ethics

Building a new global understanding of African business — on African terms

The UCT GSB's new director, Dr Catherine Duggan, has often been asked why she wants to work in Africa — it's a question this award-winning lecturer and former Harvard academic just loves to answer.

Read Article
Posted on 20 August 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
In a world impacted by COVID-19 - MEDIA
Leadership & Ethics

In a world impacted by COVID-19, women leaders can make the difference

The disruption brought on by the global COVID-19 pandemic may be seen by some companies as an excuse to dial back on diversity and inclusion - but this would be a mistake as studies show women handle crises better.

Read Article
Posted on 7 August 2020 by Kumeshnee West
 Values-Based-Leadership - media
Leadership & Ethics

Values-based leadership in the age of COVID-19

Dr Camaren Peter, associate professor with the Allan Gray Centre for Values-Based Leadership at the UCT Graduate School of Business, speaks about the challenges posed by the global COVID-19 pandemic.

Read Article
Posted on 13 July 2020 by Camaren Peter
nelson mandela - mandela
Leadership & Ethics

SA needs leaders who are willing to step out of their comfort zones

As the country plunges deeper into an economic and humanitarian crisis fuelled by the COVID-19 pandemic, we will need steward leaders who are accountable and focused on assisting their communities — and each of us can rise to the challenge.

Read Article
Posted on 13 July 2020 by Kurt April
Jerome - media
Leadership & Ethics

Embracing the unknown can make you a better leader - Jerome Thomas (EMBA)

COVID-19 is giving leaders everywhere a crash course in living with volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity (VUCA). Fortunately, says Jerome Thomas, he got a head start with his EMBA at the UCT GSB.

Read Article
Posted on 8 June 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Sexual Harrasment - Media
Leadership & Ethics

Global MBA survey finds workplace sexual harassment is rampant

GNAM survey finds women in Africa more likely to report unwanted sexual attention but considerably less likely to report personal experiences of sexist and sexual misconduct.

Read Article
Posted on 10 March 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Do we really need another hero?
Leadership & Ethics

Do we really need another hero?

The rise of the hero leader around the world — strongmen who promise to be able to rescue their followers from difficult circumstances — is driving a wedge between citizens and undermining democratic institutions.

Read Article
Posted on 12 February 2020 by Babar Dharani
Privacy Addiction and the Role of Media
Leadership & Ethics

Privacy, addiction and the role of responsible digital marketing

Digital marketing provides an invaluable opportunity for businesses to reach more customers, better understand their needs and ultimately sell more product. But the medium is addictive and marketers have a growing duty to use it responsibly.

Read Article
Posted on 22 September 2019 by Mignon Reyneke
Believe it or not MEDIA
Leadership & Ethics

Believe it or not, the economy is not the biggest of our concerns in South Africa

South Africa has a fractured past, that we cannot deny, and divisions have always been an everyday part of life here. But these days, our differences are threatening to tear us apart.

Read Article
Posted on 16 August 2019 by Athol Williams
What is the impact of an atypical - Media
Leadership & Ethics

What is the impact of an atypical leader on diversity beliefs?

An extract from a presentation to the UCT GSB by Mustafa F. Özbilgin, Professor of Organisational Behaviour at Brunel Business School, London.

Read Article
Posted on 16 March 2019 by UCT GSB Press Office